Monday, June 5, 2023
  • Submit news
  • Contact
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
Oil Market News
  • Home
  • Marketdaily
  • Price
  • crudenow
  • Companies
  • politics
  • Gas
  • investing
  • Stock
  • OPEChot
  • brend
  • ships
Oil Market News
Home politics

Small-time investing fuels real world consequences

1 year ago
in politics
Small-time investing fuels real world consequences
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


There are many differences between the Covid-19 and 2008 financial crises. But both illustrate the way market speculation can exacerbate dangerous price swings, particularly in tumultuous times.

A recent case in point: the plunge in US crude prices last month that resulted in part from a big sell-off of West Texas Intermediate futures contracts by the country’s largest oil fund, USO.

There have been many reasons for oil prices to crash, from the massive drop in demand due to the coronavirus lockdown to the petro-politics of Russia and Saudi Arabia. But another reason was the level of speculation in oil markets.

The CME Group, a derivatives exchange, “became concerned” about the fact that USO, an exchange traded fund that deals in oil futures, had amassed a quarter of the WTI futures contract due to be delivered in June. The CME felt this was a dangerously large position, and ordered USO to scale back. At this point, furious trading ensued and June futures prices plunged.

This reminds me very much of the way in which oil prices spiked to almost $150 a barrel in 2008, even as a giant recession was taking hold.

Then, as now, there were some real supply-and-demand dynamics at work. But increased use of commodities as a financial instrument also played a role. This was brought home by hedge fund portfolio manager Michael Masters, co-founder of the non-profit financial reform advocate Better Markets, in striking Senate testimony on the topic in May 2008.

“What we are experiencing is a demand shock coming from a new category of participant in the commodities futures markets . . . corporate and government pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, university endowments, and other institutional investors,” he said, noting that such investors now hold the largest share of outstanding commodities futures contracts.

The “financialisation” of commodities, which academic research shows has distorted markets, isn’t coming just from institutions. The rise of ETFs like USO mean that plenty of retail investors are dabbling in oil derivatives too, a trend that The Oxford Institute for Energy Studies has linked to the recent collapse of WTI prices.

Even with coronavirus-related demand destruction and the saturation of global storage capacity, writes Oxford Energy author Ilia Bouchouev, “it is very unlikely that any of us could have foreseen WTI ever trading at negative $40, and the critical role that retail-oriented derivatives products played in such a historic event”.

It’s hard to understand why anyone would have wanted to be in USO, given that it had a negative 94 per cent return from its start in 2006 through to mid-April. But as the Oxford white paper notes, oil ETFs have attracted large inflows from retail investors in recent months despite such huge losses.

According to Robintrack.net, which follows the number of users holding each asset on the online trading platform Robinhood, there were a record 220,905 user accounts holding the USO fund at the end of April, almost 30 times more than two months earlier.

All this is part of a long-term trend towards retail investors using low-cost vehicles like ETFs to take part in a specific investing trend that was hitherto only available to professionals — for example, using oil as a financial asset class to hedge against inflation and geopolitical events.

In some ways, ETFs are just the latest iteration of a trend that began with index funds, and has extended to low cost brokerages, e-trading platforms, and even fintech robo-advising.

That’s not a bad thing, per se. In fact, you could argue that it’s only fair for the little guy to be able to get the same upside as market professionals. But of course, that means they get the downside, too. New technology platforms such as Robinhood (which added 3m users in 2020, half of them first-time investors) allow novices to make such bets in the blink of an eye.

“I’d wager that 90 per cent of investors in USO couldn’t explain what contango is,” says Mr Masters, referring to the difference between spot and futures prices that traders must try to navigate.

Now that oil ETFs have imploded and USO’s own broker, RBC, has refused to place more orders, some are undoubtedly figuring it out. That’s wise, especially given that a new rule proposed by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission could lift the Dodd-Frank position limits put in place after the post-2008 oil spike.

That may create more liquidity in the market at a time when it’s arguably needed. But it could also pour kerosene on the next bout of market volatility.

That could come from more sudden price drops, if the reopening of the US economy doesn’t go well. Or it could mean a sudden spike of inflation if strong demand coincides with record monetary easing and asset purchases by the US Federal Reserve.

The CFTC itself has issued a warning about the risks of investment products linked to commodity futures. Dan Berkovitz, one of the CFTC commissioners who smartly voted against the loosening of position limits, has summed up the situation.

“When the oil market gets volatile, whether its trending up as we did in 2008 or trending down now, we see an increase in interest in these funds exacerbating the trends that we’re in and even affecting the physical markets,” he has said.

Then, as now, treating fuel as a Wall Street instrument has real world consequences as well.

rana.foroohar@ft.com

Follow Rana Foroohar with myFT and on Twitter





www.ft.com

Latest Oil News

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

February 1, 2023
Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

January 31, 2023
Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

January 30, 2023
MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

January 29, 2023
Tags: consequencesfuelsinvestingrealSmalltimeWORLD
Previous Post

US Sector Forecast – Energy Shares Move higher Following Rising Crude Oil Prices

Next Post

CNOOC’s $13bn oil, gas deals show China’s supply fears

Related Posts

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

by Oil Market News
February 1, 2023
0

CNN  —  The Interior Department’s Bureau of Land Management on Wednesday advanced the controversial Willow oil drilling project on Alaska’s...

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

by Oil Market News
January 31, 2023
0

The 59th annual volume of the Socialist Register examines the growth of corporate power and other important organizational trends in...

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

by Oil Market News
January 30, 2023
0

I was trying to do something I never do: take a two-day vacation.  I had been in Peru for a...

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

by Oil Market News
January 29, 2023
0

BY BASSEY UDO At a critical juncture when Nigeria’s back is against the wall, the impending reinvigoration of the Ministry...

Italy, Libya sign $8B gas deal as PM Meloni visits Tripoli

Italy, Libya sign $8B gas deal as PM Meloni visits Tripoli

by Oil Market News
January 28, 2023
0

CAIRO (AP) — Italy’s prime minister held talks in Libya on Saturday with officials from the country’s west-based government focusing...

Moody’s upgrades Alberta government’s credit profile

Moody’s upgrades Alberta government’s credit profile

by Oil Market News
January 27, 2023
0

Article content The Alberta government’s credit profile has been upgraded on the back of the continued high price of oil....

Next Post
CNOOC’s $13bn oil, gas deals show China’s supply fears

CNOOC’s $13bn oil, gas deals show China’s supply fears

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Trend Oil News

These Troubled Oil Stocks Are Crashing Today

These Troubled Oil Stocks Are Crashing Today

1 year ago
Live news updates: US mortgage rates fall below 5% for the first time since April

Live news updates: US mortgage rates fall below 5% for the first time since April

10 months ago
Crude Oil Falls on Dollar Strength and Chinese Demand Concerns – Barchart

Crude Oil Falls on Dollar Strength and Chinese Demand Concerns – Barchart

11 months ago
America’s Oil And Natural Gas Investments Must Continue Apace

America’s Oil And Natural Gas Investments Must Continue Apace

1 year ago
OPEC further slashes 2020 world oil demand forecast, but makes ‘huge’ cut in supply

Oil futures mark first gain in 4 sessions

8 months ago
ADVERTISEMENT
Saudi Arabia seeks to boost oil price with output cut of 1mn barrels a day

Saudi Arabia seeks to boost oil price with output cut of 1mn barrels a day

June 5, 2023

Opec bans prominent media groups from Vienna meeting

June 4, 2023

Saudi Arabia’s ‘prickly prince’ of oil bristles as crude price slides

June 3, 2023

Nigeria president’s move to end petrol subsidies sparks chaos

June 2, 2023

Exxon and Chevron shareholders cut support for climate resolutions

June 1, 2023

Opinion: Time is up for Big Oil’s business model

May 31, 2023

Crude Oil

4 Days from Deadline, EU Fails To Agree On Russian Oil Products Price Cap

4 Days from Deadline, EU Fails To Agree On Russian Oil Products Price Cap

February 1, 2023
Oil rises after U.S. fuel stocks draw down; economic concerns loom

Oil prices settle steady on higher U.S. demand, weaker dollar

January 31, 2023
S&P 500 Down 1%; Crude Oil Drops Over 2%

S&P 500 Down 1%; Crude Oil Drops Over 2%

January 30, 2023
Russia Can’t Replace the Energy Market Putin Broke

Russia Can’t Replace the Energy Market Putin Broke

January 29, 2023

Investing

Orbital Sidekick Raises $10M Investment to Monitor Oil and Gas Industry from Space 

Orbital Sidekick Raises $10M Investment to Monitor Oil and Gas Industry from Space 

February 1, 2023
Crude Oil Shielded From Bond and Stock Market Rout

Clean-energy investing poised to top money backing oil and gas after hitting a record

January 31, 2023
Crude Oil Shielded From Bond and Stock Market Rout

The Cushing® MLP & Infrastructure Total Return Fund Announces Fund Name Change

January 30, 2023
Boeing’s 747, the original jumbo jet, prepares for final send-off By Reuters

Boeing’s 747, the original jumbo jet, prepares for final send-off By Reuters

January 29, 2023

Market

Saudi Arabia seeks to boost oil price with output cut of 1mn barrels a day

Saudi Arabia seeks to boost oil price with output cut of 1mn barrels a day

June 5, 2023
Opec bans prominent media groups from Vienna meeting

Opec bans prominent media groups from Vienna meeting

June 4, 2023
Saudi Arabia’s ‘prickly prince’ of oil bristles as crude price slides

Saudi Arabia’s ‘prickly prince’ of oil bristles as crude price slides

June 3, 2023
Nigeria president’s move to end petrol subsidies sparks chaos

Nigeria president’s move to end petrol subsidies sparks chaos

June 2, 2023

OPEC

US Close- Fed signals more hikes coming, Powell says disinflation process begun, ADP

US Close- Fed signals more hikes coming, Powell says disinflation process begun, ADP

February 1, 2023
‘OPEC does not control the price’: OPEC President | OPEC News

‘OPEC does not control the price’: OPEC President | OPEC News

January 31, 2023
OPEC+ Closely Watches Chinese Factory Data

OPEC+ Closely Watches Chinese Factory Data

January 30, 2023
Week Ahead: FOMC, BOE, ECB, OPEC, NFP and Big Tech Earnings

Week Ahead: FOMC, BOE, ECB, OPEC, NFP and Big Tech Earnings

January 29, 2023
  • Submit news
  • Contact
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2022 OilMarket.News

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Market
  • Price
  • crude
  • Companies
  • politics
  • Gas
  • investing
  • Stock
  • OPEC
  • brend
  • ships

© 2022 OilMarket.News

wpDiscuz
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.