Thursday, June 8, 2023
  • Submit news
  • Contact
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
Oil Market News
  • Home
  • Marketdaily
  • Price
  • crudenow
  • Companies
  • politics
  • Gas
  • investing
  • Stock
  • OPEChot
  • brend
  • ships
Oil Market News
Home politics

Gas Prices Debate Reveals A Lot About U.S. Politics

11 months ago
in politics
Gas Prices Debate Reveals A Lot About U.S. Politics
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


Who’s responsible for the high gas prices that have taken hold across the U.S.? If you listen to your average Republican, you’ll hear blame placed on the energy and climate policies of the Biden Administration—with some even suggesting that a nefarious “Green New Deal” has led to the price hike. Meanwhile, Democrats, including many in the Biden White House, will point to “price gouging” by greedy oil and gas executives who are manipulating consumers.

Depending on how generous you’re feeling, these explanations are half truths, at best, or bald-faced lies, at worst. High gas prices are the result of a complex set of circumstances—including the Russian invasion of Ukraine, supply chain challenges, and other market dynamics—and can’t be easily boiled down into a talking point.

Latest Oil News

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

February 1, 2023
Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

January 31, 2023
Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

January 30, 2023
MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

January 29, 2023

Of course, it’s easy enough to understand why politicians, oil executives, and political commentators have relied on such rhetoric. Elected officials are jockeying for votes and political sway in the midst of a heated election year while fossil fuel companies are fighting to secure a profitable future amid the clean energy transition. With these stakes, it’s hard to imagine any player changing course and embracing nuanced, heady positions about the economic and political factors contributing to high gas prices.

But details matter as we consider the challenges of transitioning our economy away from fossil fuels and addressing the now-inevitable and already unfolding impacts of climate change. And the current debate around gas prices tells us a lot about how policymakers can miss the forest for the trees.

To understand the misrepresentations around gas prices, it’s helpful to look first to Republicans, who have been using climate as a political cudgel for decades. Republicans have repeatedly used the argument that climate policy will cost consumers to deflect any and every legislative attempt to reduce emissions. So it came as little surprise that they blamed Biden and his climate agenda when gas prices started to rise, in some cases asserting that his “Green New Deal” had driven up prices.


A version of this story first appeared in the Climate is Everything newsletter. To sign up, click here.


“In some parts of the country, the price has crossed $6.90 a gallon. This was not an accident,” Sen. Ted Cruz (R., Texas) said during a meeting of the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation. “This was the result of the Green New Deal zealots in the Biden Administration.”

It almost goes without saying that this—especially in the most extreme version—is totally false. Biden has struggled to implement even basic climate policy, let alone anything close to a Green New Deal. Moreover, the Administration has been working furiously to find any policy lever to reduce gas prices, understanding that high gas prices portend poor political outcomes.

If there is a small kernel of truth amid the unfounded rhetoric, it is that the Administration has sought from the very first days in office to send a market signal that fossil fuels broadly are not the future. Indeed, Biden and others in the Administration have argued that such a signal is among their greatest contributions to the climate fight. This dynamic, which is loose to say the least, is hard to quantify and certainly not a primary factor in the high gas price environment we find ourselves in, but it is part of the broader global consensus that money should be shifted away from fossil fuel investment. This is an important point. As the energy transition advances, policymakers pushing climate policy will need to be able to make the case for a continued shift of investment away from fossil fuels and toward clean energy—even amid volatile fossil fuel prices.

The Democratic talking points take a bit more explanation. Activists who oppose the oil and gas industry have pointed to the fact that the industry is making record profits as evidence that executives are ripping off American consumers. Many Congressional Democrats have run with that line of reasoning, introducing anti-price gouging legislation. Meanwhile, President Biden called on the Federal Trade Commission to launch a consumer protection investigation last November as gas prices began to rise even before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. “The Federal Trade Commission has authority to consider whether illegal conduct is costing families at the pump,” Biden wrote in November. “I do not accept hard-working Americans paying more for gas because of anti-competitive or otherwise potentially illegal conduct.”

It’s certainly true that energy companies are enjoying record profits this year as oil prices have soared. But generating a large profit doesn’t necessarily—or even usually—equal price gouging. Oil prices have risen because demand has risen (the economy continues to grow post-COVID) while supply has fallen (Russian oil is no longer welcome across much of the world). In this environment, U.S. producers are simply maintaining the course. This, some Democrats claim, is evidence of price gouging because, they say, companies should be responding to market pressures and produce more.

It’s true that U.S. oil companies could plan to ramp up their production, though it would take months to years before this affects the market. Oil companies don’t want to do that out of fear that more production could lead to too much production and drive down prices—and profits. Indeed, overproduction led to years of losses for the industry in the last decade. So while it’s obvious that oil executives are looking after their profit, it’s unclear how that adds up to price gouging. A recent report from the Congressional Research Service boils down its definition of price gouging to “unfair” inflation of prices by companies to take advantage of an emergency situation.

Why am I bothering to split hairs about this rhetoric? To my mind, not only do these talking points serve as a distraction, but they also misrepresent the nature of our energy and climate challenges. The Republican rhetoric is simply wrong, suggesting that Democrats have imposed draconian climate policies when in fact the world needs far more aggressive action. The higher-level problem with Democratic rhetoric is a little more subtle. The problem isn’t that companies are violating American laws and norms by engaging in practices like price gouging; the problem is that American laws and norms haven’t adjusted to the energy and climate challenges we face today. Not only is it perfectly legal to dump carbon pollution into the atmosphere while earning a massive profit, but the government supports and subsidizes the practice. The sooner we speak honestly about our challenges, the sooner we can solve them.

More Must-Read Stories From TIME


Write to Justin Worland at justin.worland@time.com.



time.com

Tags: debateGaslotpoliticspricesreveals
Previous Post

Crude oil, energy stocks claw back some losses from two-day rout (NYSEARCA:USO)

Next Post

Gasoline prices dip a quarter from recent 5-dollar highs

Related Posts

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

by Oil Market News
February 1, 2023
0

CNN  —  The Interior Department’s Bureau of Land Management on Wednesday advanced the controversial Willow oil drilling project on Alaska’s...

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

by Oil Market News
January 31, 2023
0

The 59th annual volume of the Socialist Register examines the growth of corporate power and other important organizational trends in...

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

by Oil Market News
January 30, 2023
0

I was trying to do something I never do: take a two-day vacation.  I had been in Peru for a...

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

by Oil Market News
January 29, 2023
0

BY BASSEY UDO At a critical juncture when Nigeria’s back is against the wall, the impending reinvigoration of the Ministry...

Italy, Libya sign $8B gas deal as PM Meloni visits Tripoli

Italy, Libya sign $8B gas deal as PM Meloni visits Tripoli

by Oil Market News
January 28, 2023
0

CAIRO (AP) — Italy’s prime minister held talks in Libya on Saturday with officials from the country’s west-based government focusing...

Moody’s upgrades Alberta government’s credit profile

Moody’s upgrades Alberta government’s credit profile

by Oil Market News
January 27, 2023
0

Article content The Alberta government’s credit profile has been upgraded on the back of the continued high price of oil....

Next Post
Gasoline prices dip a quarter from recent 5-dollar highs

Gasoline prices dip a quarter from recent 5-dollar highs

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Trend Oil News

Oil Demand Is Returning, but Prices Are Still Too Low

Oil Demand Is Returning, but Prices Are Still Too Low

1 year ago
OPEC and maximum production: What is sustainable?

OPEC and maximum production: What is sustainable?

11 months ago
US oil producers defy calls to open taps and tame war-driven energy prices

US oil producers defy calls to open taps and tame war-driven energy prices

10 months ago
BP Snags Contract To Market Guyana’s Share Of Exxon’s Offshore Oil

BP Snags Contract To Market Guyana’s Share Of Exxon’s Offshore Oil

6 months ago
Mexican companies face higher electricity charges

Mexican companies face higher electricity charges

1 year ago
ADVERTISEMENT
Canadian refiner Irving Oil explores options including sale

Canadian refiner Irving Oil explores options including sale

June 8, 2023

UK watchdog bans Shell, Repsol and Petronas greenwashing ads

June 7, 2023

Opec+ is not on board with Saudi’s ‘whatever it takes’ message

June 6, 2023

Saudi Arabia seeks to boost oil price with output cut of 1mn barrels a day

June 5, 2023

Opec bans prominent media groups from Vienna meeting

June 4, 2023

Saudi Arabia’s ‘prickly prince’ of oil bristles as crude price slides

June 3, 2023

Crude Oil

4 Days from Deadline, EU Fails To Agree On Russian Oil Products Price Cap

4 Days from Deadline, EU Fails To Agree On Russian Oil Products Price Cap

February 1, 2023
Oil rises after U.S. fuel stocks draw down; economic concerns loom

Oil prices settle steady on higher U.S. demand, weaker dollar

January 31, 2023
S&P 500 Down 1%; Crude Oil Drops Over 2%

S&P 500 Down 1%; Crude Oil Drops Over 2%

January 30, 2023
Russia Can’t Replace the Energy Market Putin Broke

Russia Can’t Replace the Energy Market Putin Broke

January 29, 2023

Investing

Orbital Sidekick Raises $10M Investment to Monitor Oil and Gas Industry from Space 

Orbital Sidekick Raises $10M Investment to Monitor Oil and Gas Industry from Space 

February 1, 2023
Crude Oil Shielded From Bond and Stock Market Rout

Clean-energy investing poised to top money backing oil and gas after hitting a record

January 31, 2023
Crude Oil Shielded From Bond and Stock Market Rout

The Cushing® MLP & Infrastructure Total Return Fund Announces Fund Name Change

January 30, 2023
Boeing’s 747, the original jumbo jet, prepares for final send-off By Reuters

Boeing’s 747, the original jumbo jet, prepares for final send-off By Reuters

January 29, 2023

Market

Canadian refiner Irving Oil explores options including sale

Canadian refiner Irving Oil explores options including sale

June 8, 2023
UK watchdog bans Shell, Repsol and Petronas greenwashing ads

UK watchdog bans Shell, Repsol and Petronas greenwashing ads

June 7, 2023
Opec+ is not on board with Saudi’s ‘whatever it takes’ message

Opec+ is not on board with Saudi’s ‘whatever it takes’ message

June 6, 2023
Saudi Arabia seeks to boost oil price with output cut of 1mn barrels a day

Saudi Arabia seeks to boost oil price with output cut of 1mn barrels a day

June 5, 2023

OPEC

US Close- Fed signals more hikes coming, Powell says disinflation process begun, ADP

US Close- Fed signals more hikes coming, Powell says disinflation process begun, ADP

February 1, 2023
‘OPEC does not control the price’: OPEC President | OPEC News

‘OPEC does not control the price’: OPEC President | OPEC News

January 31, 2023
OPEC+ Closely Watches Chinese Factory Data

OPEC+ Closely Watches Chinese Factory Data

January 30, 2023
Week Ahead: FOMC, BOE, ECB, OPEC, NFP and Big Tech Earnings

Week Ahead: FOMC, BOE, ECB, OPEC, NFP and Big Tech Earnings

January 29, 2023
  • Submit news
  • Contact
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2022 OilMarket.News

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Market
  • Price
  • crude
  • Companies
  • politics
  • Gas
  • investing
  • Stock
  • OPEC
  • brend
  • ships

© 2022 OilMarket.News

wpDiscuz
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.