Tuesday, March 28, 2023
  • Submit news
  • Contact
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
Oil Market News
  • Home
  • Marketdaily
  • Price
  • crudenow
  • Companies
  • politics
  • Gas
  • investing
  • Stock
  • OPEChot
  • brend
  • ships
Oil Market News
Home politics

Democracies must modernise their laws to protect freedoms in the era of technological

11 months ago
in politics
Democracies must modernise their laws to protect freedoms in the era of technological
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


India’s recent skirmish with Twitter is not an isolated case where a government has locked horns with US tech giants that have acquired a larger-than-life presence across the world. Nowhere have the arguments on big tech been more intense than in the US, where the last two general elections in 2016 and 2020 have seen strong charges of political manipulation by social media companies.

The story is not just about the oversized role of social media companies in elections. It envelops a range of domestic and international issues including the concentration of economic power, individual rights against the state as well as the corporation, disinformation, the rise of digital geopolitics, and global digital governance.

While China has come up with clear answers, for good or bad, to the new digital questions, liberal societies around the world are struggling to address the challenges to democratic forms of governance that emerged with the modern industrial society.

No one country or corporation in the free world can credibly preach to others on the right path to digital salvation. Democratic forces need to consult each other and collaborate in developing new norms for managing the digital world.

In the US, both the left and right are demanding that digital behemoths like Amazon, Google, Facebook and Twitter are brought under greater control if not broken up. The US has had a long political tradition of breaking monopolies going back to the progressive politics at the turn of the 20th century that targeted the concentration of power in the oil, rail road, and steel industries. In December, the US government filed a lawsuit against Facebook for anti-competitive practices in more than 40 states. Google and Amazon are also under legal scrutiny.

The current digital giants, however, are not easily amenable to political attack. They are bigger than the biggest we have known. They donate massively to political campaigns in the US and have an enormous influence on the legislative process in Washington. That makes the domestic battles against big tech in the US that much more interesting.

As the US takes a close look at the anti-competitive practices of the tech giants, Europe is not far behind. Last December, the European Commission proposed new rules to promote competition and fairness in digital markets. The EU is likely to approve a Digital Markets Act next year.

The war is playing out in multiple other theatres. In Australia, the government is staring down a threat from Google to shut a developed nation of 25 million people out of its popular search engine. The provocation? Canberra has decreed that Google must work out an arrangement with Australian newspapers to pay for the use of their content.

Google worries, rightly, that this will set a precedent for other governments and will undermine its revenues. Many governments in the developed world are cheering for Canberra. So is Microsoft, which is offering its Bing search engine as a more sensible alternative to Australia.

For more than two decades, governments across the world were happy to buy into the claim that the tech companies will lead us to a world of innovation and plenty. Legal and financial concessions from governments at various levels allowed tech companies to rapidly gain ground and commercial muscle and dominate people’s lives. But governments are now questioning the sharp business practices of the tech giants.

Let us highlight three issues here — labour rights, taxes and politics. While the tech giants have created a lot of new wealth, some of them have sharply squeezed the labour. Amazon is the most notorious. There are new efforts to unionise Amazon employees, but the company has been good at crushing these challenges in the past. In California, trade unions are battling against the success of Uber and Lyft to turn employees into “contract workers” to deny them multiple benefits.

Digital giants have been aggressive tax evaders. But Caesar is demanding his due now. Joe Biden, who has outlined a progressive platform, has promised to get big tech to pay their share of taxes in the US. His Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen is under pressure from America’s G-7 partners to work out the rules for taxes on US digital giants operating in other geographies.

On the political front, when Twitter and Facebook shut down President Donald Trump’s accounts, there was celebration among liberals. But social media companies are unlikely to always find themselves on the winning side in other democracies. The context and issues are inevitably different and applying the same tactics against political targets will backfire, as Twitter discovered in Delhi.

If India raised Twitter’s differential treatment of the riots in Washington and Delhi, European leaders raised important questions about social media’s actions against Trump. German Chancellor Angela Merkel spoke for many Europeans when she called it “problematic”.

The European Commissioner for internal markets, Thierry Breton, expanded on the issues involved. “The fact that a CEO can pull the plug” on an elected President of the world’s most powerful nation “without any checks and balances” “displays deep weaknesses in the way our society is organised in the digital space,” he warned.

The answer, Breton insists, lies in laying down a clear set of obligations and responsibilities for the digital giants; he promises that the EU’s proposed Digital Services Act will do that. The moves in Brussels are in part about restoring the primacy of elected governments. They are also about building “digital sovereignty” that will let Europe make its own choices based on its own values.

Even as it claims digital sovereignty, Europe has offered to open talks with the Biden administration on the full range of digital issues that have emerged. The idea that the world’s democracies must get together to discuss global digital governance is gaining ground. Delhi is likely to be part of some of the initial conversations.

The promised utopia of a digital domain free from states and borders was always a chimaera. The digital holiday is over and the state is back. States, at least the strong ones, whether authoritarian or democratic, were not simply going to cede their right to govern to technology companies.

Reports that Twitter, after some initial defiance, has complied with much of the Indian government’s demands, points to an easily forgotten reality. Twitter, like all other big tech companies, is a commercial beast and will live or die by its bottom line. Large states have the power to change that calculus.

As governments push back against big tech, a new challenge presents itself — reining in the growing power of the state in the digital age. The answer lies in democracies modernising their laws to protect freedoms in the era of technological transformation. Twitter is of little help in this urgent but demanding domestic political battle.

This article first appeared in the print edition on February 16, 2021 under the title ‘New digital question and answers’. The writer is director, Institute of South Asian Studies, National University of Singapore and contributing editor on international affairs for The Indian Express



indianexpress.com

Latest Oil News

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

February 1, 2023
Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

January 31, 2023
Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

January 30, 2023
MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

January 29, 2023
Tags: Apar Gupta writesDemocraciesEraFarm lawsFarm laws protestsfreedom to speech freedom of expressionfreedomsIndian express columnIT Actlawsmoderniseprotectright to receive informationtechnologicalTwitterTwitter accounts suspendedTwitter modi govt
Previous Post

Interior Secretary Nominee on Collision Course With Oil Industry

Next Post

Oil War Helps Santos Complete Purchase of ConocoPhillips Assets At A Discount –

Related Posts

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

Biden administration takes another step toward advancing a controversial oil drilling

by Oil Market News
February 1, 2023
0

CNN  —  The Interior Department’s Bureau of Land Management on Wednesday advanced the controversial Willow oil drilling project on Alaska’s...

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

Monthly Review | NEW! SOCIALIST REGISTER 2023 (EXCERPTS)

by Oil Market News
January 31, 2023
0

The 59th annual volume of the Socialist Register examines the growth of corporate power and other important organizational trends in...

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

Inside the Fight to Save the Peruvian Amazon From Big Oil – Rolling Stone

by Oil Market News
January 30, 2023
0

I was trying to do something I never do: take a two-day vacation.  I had been in Peru for a...

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

MOFI: Nigeria’s strategic vision for sustainable economic recovery

by Oil Market News
January 29, 2023
0

BY BASSEY UDO At a critical juncture when Nigeria’s back is against the wall, the impending reinvigoration of the Ministry...

Italy, Libya sign $8B gas deal as PM Meloni visits Tripoli

Italy, Libya sign $8B gas deal as PM Meloni visits Tripoli

by Oil Market News
January 28, 2023
0

CAIRO (AP) — Italy’s prime minister held talks in Libya on Saturday with officials from the country’s west-based government focusing...

Moody’s upgrades Alberta government’s credit profile

Moody’s upgrades Alberta government’s credit profile

by Oil Market News
January 27, 2023
0

Article content The Alberta government’s credit profile has been upgraded on the back of the continued high price of oil....

Next Post
Oil War Helps Santos Complete Purchase of ConocoPhillips Assets At A Discount –

Oil War Helps Santos Complete Purchase of ConocoPhillips Assets At A Discount –

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Trend Oil News

New Mexico families in oil and gas ‘waste zone’ seek help | Earthbeat

New Mexico families in oil and gas ‘waste zone’ seek help | Earthbeat

11 months ago
Eni chief predicts gas market will remain tight for at least four years

Eni chief predicts gas market will remain tight for at least four years

11 months ago
ESG focus leads to dwindling numbers of new petroleum engineers

Young shale CEOs eye output boost in oil patch struggling to grow

7 months ago
Why are we settling for inflation?

Why are we settling for inflation?

2 months ago
Mexican energy companies lag methane emission rules, investigators say

Mexican energy companies lag methane emission rules, investigators say

2 months ago
ADVERTISEMENT
‘Full investigation’ promised into UK wildlife haven oil spill

‘Full investigation’ promised into UK wildlife haven oil spill

March 27, 2023

Libyan state oil chief stresses support across divided country

March 26, 2023

Iraq wins landmark case against Turkey over Kurdish oil exports

March 25, 2023

UK government expected to offer energy companies windfall tax relief

March 24, 2023

Fears of an energy price surge percolate through sector

March 23, 2023

US regulator vows ‘aggressive’ crackdown on oil and gas methane leaks

March 22, 2023

Crude Oil

4 Days from Deadline, EU Fails To Agree On Russian Oil Products Price Cap

4 Days from Deadline, EU Fails To Agree On Russian Oil Products Price Cap

February 1, 2023
Oil rises after U.S. fuel stocks draw down; economic concerns loom

Oil prices settle steady on higher U.S. demand, weaker dollar

January 31, 2023
S&P 500 Down 1%; Crude Oil Drops Over 2%

S&P 500 Down 1%; Crude Oil Drops Over 2%

January 30, 2023
Russia Can’t Replace the Energy Market Putin Broke

Russia Can’t Replace the Energy Market Putin Broke

January 29, 2023

Investing

Orbital Sidekick Raises $10M Investment to Monitor Oil and Gas Industry from Space 

Orbital Sidekick Raises $10M Investment to Monitor Oil and Gas Industry from Space 

February 1, 2023
Crude Oil Shielded From Bond and Stock Market Rout

Clean-energy investing poised to top money backing oil and gas after hitting a record

January 31, 2023
Crude Oil Shielded From Bond and Stock Market Rout

The Cushing® MLP & Infrastructure Total Return Fund Announces Fund Name Change

January 30, 2023
Boeing’s 747, the original jumbo jet, prepares for final send-off By Reuters

Boeing’s 747, the original jumbo jet, prepares for final send-off By Reuters

January 29, 2023

Market

‘Full investigation’ promised into UK wildlife haven oil spill

‘Full investigation’ promised into UK wildlife haven oil spill

March 27, 2023
Libyan state oil chief stresses support across divided country

Libyan state oil chief stresses support across divided country

March 26, 2023
Iraq wins landmark case against Turkey over Kurdish oil exports

Iraq wins landmark case against Turkey over Kurdish oil exports

March 25, 2023
UK government expected to offer energy companies windfall tax relief

UK government expected to offer energy companies windfall tax relief

March 24, 2023

OPEC

US Close- Fed signals more hikes coming, Powell says disinflation process begun, ADP

US Close- Fed signals more hikes coming, Powell says disinflation process begun, ADP

February 1, 2023
‘OPEC does not control the price’: OPEC President | OPEC News

‘OPEC does not control the price’: OPEC President | OPEC News

January 31, 2023
OPEC+ Closely Watches Chinese Factory Data

OPEC+ Closely Watches Chinese Factory Data

January 30, 2023
Week Ahead: FOMC, BOE, ECB, OPEC, NFP and Big Tech Earnings

Week Ahead: FOMC, BOE, ECB, OPEC, NFP and Big Tech Earnings

January 29, 2023
  • Submit news
  • Contact
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2022 OilMarket.News

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Market
  • Price
  • crude
  • Companies
  • politics
  • Gas
  • investing
  • Stock
  • OPEC
  • brend
  • ships

© 2022 OilMarket.News

wpDiscuz
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.